Magazine

Editors Pick

How eBay can be more than just a side-hustle

BBC News

Public sector pay deals help drive up UK borrowing

Borrowing was £17.4bn last month, the second highest October figure since monthly records began in 1993.

who is sarah tucker
17th November 2026

Sarah Tucker: First Create the Problem, then Sell the Cure

Sarah Tucker

The most profitable business model may also be the most ridiculous.

Somewhere in the world, a business is making life unnecessarily complicated while another is preparing an expensive solution to the complication. Occasionally, they are the same business, which demonstrates a level of commercial efficiency that would impress even the most imaginative management consultant. We have become extraordinarily accomplished at selling people relief from difficulties that competent organisations might have prevented in the first place.

The wellness industry provides a particularly entertaining example. Sleep is no longer something we do but something we optimise, rest requires instruction and even breathing, an activity most of us have managed without professional supervision since birth, is now available as a specialist service. I teach yoga and fully appreciate the benefits of learning how to breathe properly, but I wonder whether the relentless conversion of ordinary human activities into commercial opportunities has begun to obscure what customers actually need.

Consider the exhausted employee whose organisation expects constant availability, arranges meetings throughout the working day and regards answering messages at midnight as evidence of commitment. Rather than addressing these practices, the employer introduces a resilience programme designed to help staff manage stress. Everybody benefits except, potentially, the exhausted employee, who now has another appointment to attend and a growing suspicion that failure to cope is a personal shortcoming.

This arrangement illustrates a fundamental business error: confusing the customer’s ability to tolerate a problem with the elimination of the problem itself. Training somebody to negotiate an unnecessarily complicated booking system is not the same as making the system straightforward. Offering stress management to a workforce with impossible deadlines is not equivalent to introducing manageable deadlines. Providing customers with ever more sophisticated instructions may demonstrate expertise, but it can also advertise an organisation’s inability to simplify its own operations.

For entrepreneurs, the opportunity lies in reversing the conventional question. Instead of asking what additional products, features or services people want, ask which existing demands they would happily see disappear. What do they find frustrating, unnecessarily time-consuming or faintly insulting? Which tasks have businesses transferred to customers under the reassuring description of convenience?

A hotel might discover that guests don’t particularly want more elaborate personalisation but would appreciate being able to speak to a human being. A restaurant might find that customers prefer a reliable booking system to an app promising an immersive dining journey. A travel company might discover that the most memorable part of its carefully curated itinerary was the afternoon guests were allowed to spend doing whatever they pleased.

These examples reveal another problem with conventional business thinking. Organisations become attached to their products, processes and terminology, while customers remain interested in what those things actually do for them. The provider sells a transformational experience; the customer wants a break. The company offers an integrated communications platform; the user wants to find the relevant information without needing an instruction manual. The distinction is not trivial, particularly when the customer is paying for the privilege of doing work the business should have completed.

There is an equally revealing difference between what customers purchase and what they subsequently remember. A traveller books a walking holiday for exercise but returns talking about an unexpected conversation. Somebody joins a class to acquire a skill and discovers the pleasure of being a beginner. A hotel guest remembers the kindness of a receptionist rather than the expensive design feature somebody spent months selecting.

The business temptation is to turn these incidental pleasures into additional products, preferably accompanied by a premium price. If guests enjoy meeting each other, introduce compulsory connection sessions; if they find solitude restorative, offer structured silence; if they appreciate having no responsibilities, create an elaborate programme explaining how to relinquish them. The unexpected benefit becomes another contractual obligation, and the customer discovers that even doing nothing now requires satisfactory participation.

This is not an argument against innovation, commercial ambition or properly delivered wellness services. It is an argument for distinguishing genuine value from organisational busyness, particularly when the latter is considerably easier to measure. The length of a programme, complexity of a product and number of available features provide reassuring evidence that a company has been working extremely hard, but none necessarily demonstrates that life has become easier for its customers.

The same lesson applies internally. Entrepreneurs often celebrate the capacity to work extraordinarily long hours, overcome endless obstacles and remain permanently available, when the more impressive accomplishment might be designing a business that doesn’t demand such behaviour. A company whose success depends upon everybody continually rescuing it from its own inefficiencies hasn’t necessarily discovered the secret of exceptional performance.

The most useful commercial exercise might therefore be an audit of unnecessary effort. Examine every stage of the customer experience and ask what could be removed without diminishing value. Then examine the organisation itself, identifying meetings, reporting requirements and approval processes that exist because nobody has previously challenged them. The savings may be financial, but the more important gain could be an improvement in how people experience the business.

There is an uncomfortable implication for industries built upon helping people cope. If you genuinely solve the underlying problem, you may reduce demand for the remedy. A business committed entirely to repeat interventions has an obvious commercial incentive to keep customers returning, whereas one committed to solving a problem might eventually render part of its own offering unnecessary.

That is where entrepreneurial judgement becomes more interesting than entrepreneurial enthusiasm. The worthwhile business is not always the one that discovers another need to monetise, but the one prepared to challenge the assumption that the need should exist at all.

Before launching another product designed to improve people’s lives, founders might ask whether their customers would be better served by having one fewer thing to manage. A business that can genuinely remove unnecessary complexity has achieved something valuable, while one that manufactures inconvenience and then charges for its removal has achieved something else entirely.

It may be profitable, but I wouldn’t necessarily call it progress.

Employability Portal

University Careers Service Rankings.
Best Global Cities to Work in.
Mentor Directory.
HR heads.

Useful Links

Education Committee
Work & Pensions
Business Energy
Working
Employment & Labour
Multiverse
BBC Worklife
Mentoring Need to Know
Listen to our News Channel 9:00am - 5.00pm weekdays
Finito and Finito World are trade marks of the owner. We cannot accept responsibility for unsolicited submissions, manuscripts and photographs. All prices and details are correct at time of going to press, but subject to change. We take no responsibility for omissions or errors. Reproduction in whole or in part without the publisher’s written permission is strictly prohibited. All rights reserved.
© 2026 Finito World - All Rights Reserved.