Magazine

Editors Pick

How eBay can be more than just a side-hustle

BBC News

Public sector pay deals help drive up UK borrowing

Borrowing was £17.4bn last month, the second highest October figure since monthly records began in 1993.

16th November 2026

The Milburn Report: time for Burnham to show his hand

The drip-feed of proposals on youth unemployment has raised more questions than answers. Now the Prime Minister must tell us what he actually intends to do.

 

There is something unsatisfactory about the way Alan Milburn’s long-awaited report into youth unemployment has been unveiled. Over the weekend we heard about a proposed legal guarantee of work or training for young people, accompanied by the possibility of withdrawing benefits from those who refuse to participate. Now comes the suggestion that employers’ National Insurance contributions should be reduced for workers aged between 21 and 24. Earlier disclosures have concerned restrictions on health-related benefits. The report itself, the product of a year’s work, will not be published until Tuesday.

This drip-feed has done little to illuminate the problem. Instead, it has encouraged a series of disconnected arguments about individual proposals before anyone outside the process has had the opportunity to assess the whole. We need to see the report, understand its evidence and consider how its recommendations relate to one another.

The scale of the challenge is not in doubt. Nearly a million young people aged 16 to 24 are neither earning nor learning. Behind that figure lie a multitude of different circumstances: poor educational attainment, mental health difficulties, disabilities, family instability, geographical disadvantage and, increasingly, an employment market in which the traditional first rung of the ladder is becoming harder to find.

There is no reason to suppose that a single intervention will address all these problems. Indeed, one of the dangers of the present debate is that the acronym NEET encourages us to regard an enormously varied population as a single category requiring a uniform solution.

The latest National Insurance proposal at least recognises an elementary economic truth. Employers must be able to afford to employ people. The government inherited a difficult labour market, but the previous administration’s decision to increase employer National Insurance to 15 per cent while lowering the earnings threshold to £5,000 hardly made recruitment easier. It is now being suggested that the threshold for employing 21 to 24-year-olds should be doubled to £10,000, initially in sectors such as retail and hospitality.

There is an irony here. Having made employment more expensive, the state is considering making it cheaper again for a particular group. There may be good reasons for targeting younger workers, but businesses do not make hiring decisions in separate compartments. They consider their overall costs, their prospects for growth and whether another employee will generate sufficient revenue to justify the investment.

Consider the Nottingham salon owner Collette Osborne, who told the BBC that she once recruited eight apprentices a year but can no longer afford to take on any. She is inundated with applications, yet unable to provide opportunities. This is not principally a problem of youthful motivation. It is a problem of economic capacity.

Equally, Milburn’s proposed legal guarantee raises questions which cannot be settled by the attractiveness of the phrase. What exactly is being guaranteed? A job with an employer, a training place, or merely access to employment support? Who will provide these opportunities? What happens when the available training bears little relation to local vacancies? And how will the government distinguish between someone unwilling to work and someone genuinely unable to do so?

A guarantee is only as meaningful as the opportunity behind it.

None of this is to dismiss Milburn’s work. On the contrary, his apparent determination to connect welfare reform with education, training and the actual demand for labour is welcome. There is considerable merit in moving public expenditure away from managing long-term inactivity and towards preventing it. But the details matter enormously, especially when proposals involve vulnerable young people and the withdrawal of financial support.

Which brings us to Andy Burnham. The Prime Minister has described the review as a watershed moment, while declining to promise that he will accept its recommendations in full. That is understandable before publication, but it cannot remain his position for long afterwards.

Every Prime Minister must eventually decide how much political capital to spend on a difficult reform. Burnham faces a Labour Party still marked by the rebellion against Sir Keir Starmer’s welfare proposals. He can seek a broad consensus, but consensus cannot become an excuse for indefinite postponement. Nor should the language of ambition substitute for the substance of a programme.

The real test will be whether Burnham can explain which recommendations he supports, which he rejects, how the changes will be financed and when they will happen. If National Insurance reductions depend upon economic conditions improving, he must say what those conditions are. If the government intends to guarantee opportunities, it must explain who will deliver them and how success will be measured.

Young people need more than another national conversation about their difficulties. Employers need confidence that the costs and risks of taking them on will be manageable. And the public needs to know whether the government is embarking upon a serious programme of reform or merely assembling a collection of attractive announcements.

Tuesday should bring an end to the speculation. The report belongs to Milburn. What happens next belongs to Burnham.

Employability Portal

University Careers Service Rankings.
Best Global Cities to Work in.
Mentor Directory.
HR heads.

Useful Links

Education Committee
Work & Pensions
Business Energy
Working
Employment & Labour
Multiverse
BBC Worklife
Mentoring Need to Know
Listen to our News Channel 9:00am - 5.00pm weekdays
Finito and Finito World are trade marks of the owner. We cannot accept responsibility for unsolicited submissions, manuscripts and photographs. All prices and details are correct at time of going to press, but subject to change. We take no responsibility for omissions or errors. Reproduction in whole or in part without the publisher’s written permission is strictly prohibited. All rights reserved.
© 2026 Finito World - All Rights Reserved.