BBC NewsBorrowing was £17.4bn last month, the second highest October figure since monthly records began in 1993.
Alan Milburn has produced one of the most ambitious blueprints for tackling youth unemployment in a generation. But beyond the headlines about benefits and job guarantees lie difficult questions about disability, transport, care leavers, management and the changing nature of work. Can Britain really give young people a first chance?
There is a moment in almost every discussion about youth unemployment when the argument becomes abstract. We talk about incentives, entitlements, benefit thresholds and economic inactivity, as though the problem were principally one of finding the correct administrative arrangement. Somewhere in the process, the young person disappears.
Alan Milburn’s long-awaited review, published on 17 November, is a serious attempt to bring that young person back into view. Entitled From a Welfare State to a Working State, it is a sweeping examination of why almost a million people aged between 16 and 24 are neither earning nor learning, and what Britain might do about it.
The scale of the ambition is considerable. Milburn wants to move towards a society in which only around 5 per cent of young people are outside education, employment or training, compared with roughly 13 per cent today. His modelling suggests that the proposed reforms could bring another 440,000 young people into sustained employment by 2036, reducing the NEET rate to around 6.8 per cent.
It is worth observing the distinction between the aspiration and the forecast. Even if Milburn’s proposals work as intended, they will not entirely achieve his stated ambition.
There is another striking figure in the report. For every £25 spent on benefits for young people in 2024-25, Britain spent just £1 helping them towards education or employment. Milburn wants that relationship fundamentally changed.
The review’s central proposition is that government should stop treating young people primarily as recipients of welfare and start treating them as people whose capacities can be developed. It proposes a legally backed Opportunity and Support Guarantee, local Youth Opportunity Services, new hiring incentives, reform of the benefits system and much closer cooperation between education, healthcare and employers.
The Government has already endorsed the broad direction, although many of the detailed recommendations remain under consideration.
Yet the most illuminating aspects of the debate may lie outside the central political argument. In responses shared with Finito World, employers, charities, lawyers and youth organisations have identified a collection of obstacles which illustrate how complicated the journey into work really is.
Together, they suggest that the challenge is not simply to create more jobs. It is to make those jobs genuinely accessible, to equip young people to perform them and to ensure that employers have both the confidence and the competence to keep them there.
The problem of the first chance
Consider the employer who is being asked to recruit a 19-year-old with no work experience.
Milburn proposes a £3,000 payment for employers recruiting someone who has been NEET for six months. An additional £2,000 would be available where the young person faces particularly significant barriers, including care experience or disability. Businesses with fewer than 50 employees could qualify for a further £2,000 premium.
These are substantial incentives. But there is a difficulty at the heart of the proposition.
Emma Hughes, Partner and Head of HR Services at Browne Jacobson, identifies what she calls a central paradox.
“As employment risks increase – enhanced employment protections, greater legal complexity, rising costs – the rational employer response is to become more rigorous, not less.”
The result, she argues, is that employers demand stronger references and greater experience at precisely the moment when the Government wants them to take a chance on inexperienced applicants.
It is an important criticism because it connects two policy objectives which are usually considered separately: improving workers’ rights and increasing employment opportunities.
There is nothing inherently contradictory about either ambition. Young people need secure and decently paid jobs. But a small business owner contemplating the recruitment of an inexperienced employee must consider the entire cost and risk of the decision.
Hughes is particularly concerned about smaller businesses outside major cities, which often lack dedicated human resources departments or legal advisers.
Milburn is alive to the problem. Indeed, one of the more revealing findings in the report is that 72 per cent of employers who had used a hiring incentive said it had not changed the number of young people they recruited.
This raises an uncomfortable possibility: that government could spend considerable sums subsidising employment which would have happened anyway.
It also explains Milburn’s reluctance to recommend an immediate blanket reduction in employers’ National Insurance contributions for all 21 to 24-year-olds. The review cites modelling suggesting such a measure would cost approximately £5.1 billion while generating only around 38,000 additional jobs.
Instead, Milburn proposes a gradual reduction in National Insurance costs, beginning with retail and hospitality when public finances permit, alongside more targeted hiring payments.
There is economic logic in this approach. But there is also a political problem. A tax reduction dependent on future fiscal conditions offers employers little immediate certainty.
The question is whether the Government can make taking a chance on a young person a rational commercial decision, rather than an act of generosity.
Getting through the door is only the beginning
Suppose the incentive works. The young person is recruited. What happens next?
Here the Chartered Management Institute has identified what may be one of the review’s most consequential blind spots.
Ann Francke, its chief executive, welcomes the proposals but warns that recruitment is only half the battle.
“If we don’t train the managers who are charged with looking after them once they arrive, we won’t see benefits for either the young people or their employers.”
Francke cites CMI research suggesting that only 6 per cent of managers believe young people possess the skills needed to thrive in the workplace, while 80 per cent of young workers regard having a trained manager as critical to developing their confidence.
These are remarkable figures. They point to a possible breakdown in expectations between generations.
Young people may enter work with insufficient experience of professional communication, feedback and workplace routines. Their managers, meanwhile, may lack the skills or patience to help them develop.
James Reed, Chair and CEO of recruitment company Reed and President of CMI, has seen the consequences.
“I’ve seen how a good manager can turn an inexperienced recruit into a confident, capable employee, while a poorly trained one can leave them struggling and out of work again within weeks.”
Reed’s point deserves particular attention because the Government’s ambitions depend on employers behaving differently, not simply hiring more people.
A successful first job is often transformative. It can establish confidence, routine, financial independence and a sense of belonging. An unsuccessful first experience can have precisely the opposite effect.
Francke warns that without investment in management, the programme risks becoming an expensive revolving door for taxpayers.
This suggests that the effectiveness of Milburn’s reforms may depend on something which is difficult to legislate for: the quality of ordinary workplace relationships.
A hiring subsidy can persuade an employer to recruit. It cannot guarantee that the person responsible for the recruit will become
a good mentor.
The young people who have already been failed
Nowhere is the distinction between formal opportunity and actual opportunity clearer than among young people leaving the care system.
According to Department for Education figures cited by Drive Forward Foundation, 40 per cent of care leavers aged 19 to 21 in England were outside education, employment or training in 2025. The comparable figure for all young people of the same age was approximately 13 per cent.
This is an extraordinary disparity.
For many young people, entering adulthood means a gradual transition supported by parents, relatives and friends. For a care leaver, it can mean taking responsibility for housing, finances and employment almost simultaneously, without a dependable family safety net.
Milburn recognises the problem and proposes a Care Leaver Transition Allowance of £50 a week for six months for those who are NEET or at serious risk, subject to an agreed participation plan.
Russell Winnard, chief executive of Drive Forward Foundation, welcomes the proposal but questions its duration.
“Six months may not be enough for those facing the greatest barriers to employment. We’d like to see flexibility built into the scheme, so that financial support doesn’t disappear just as young people are beginning to find their feet.”
There is a deeper question here about the responsibilities of the state.
If government has acted as a young person’s parent, does its responsibility end when that person turns 18? Or should it extend to helping them establish a sustainable adult life?
Drive Forward argues for a dedicated Care Leaver Jobs Guarantee, with immediate eligibility for the existing employment guarantee rather than requiring young people to spend a prolonged period claiming Universal Credit.
It also wants ring-fenced paid opportunities, including an expansion of initiatives modelled on the Civil Service Care Leaver Internship Scheme, and sustained individual support.
Winnard puts the argument succinctly: “Getting through the door is the beginning. Being able to stay, learn and progress is what changes someone’s future.”
The charity also supplied testimony from George, a 20-year-old Londoner and member of its Policy Forum.
“Sometimes appointments feel like you are in and out within five minutes, with little interest in understanding your circumstances or helping you move forward.”
This is perhaps the most devastating criticism of the existing system. A dedicated work coach sounds reassuring as a matter of policy. But if the relationship amounts to a succession of hurried appointments, the support may exist principally on paper.
Milburn’s proposed Youth Opportunity Services seek to replace fragmented provision with a single local route into assistance and a trusted individual responsible for coordinating it.
That is an important advance in principle. The test will be whether local services have the resources, authority and continuity to establish genuine relationships.
For care leavers especially, consistency may matter more than the number of programmes available.
What if the job is physically impossible to reach?
Another difficulty concerns disabled young people.
Milburn’s report contains proposals to narrow the disability employment gap, including a voluntary system under which larger employers would publish ambitions for the proportion of their young workforce who are disabled.
After five years, if progress proves insufficient, the Government could consider consulting on mandatory disability employment quotas.
It is an intriguing proposal. Yet Victoria Oliver, Partner and Head of Spinal Injury at Bolt Burdon Kemp, identifies a fundamental omission in the practical arrangements.
The review recognises that inaccessible transport can have a major impact on disabled young people, she says, but offers no sufficiently developed solution to the problem.
Oliver points to research by the Institution of Mechanical Engineers suggesting that almost half of disabled professionals have turned down employment opportunities because of transport difficulties.
The institution estimates that transport barriers effectively exclude 2.8 million people from the workforce. It also puts the cost of creating a fully accessible rail network at between £20 billion and £24 billion over several years.
These figures illuminate the limitations of an employment policy conceived primarily in terms of employers and applicants.
A disabled young person may have the skills, motivation and qualifications for a particular job. An employer may be willing to recruit them. Financial support may be available. Yet if the transport system makes travelling to work impractical, the opportunity remains theoretical.
The problem cannot be resolved through an employment guarantee alone.
Oliver argues that a change in attitudes towards disability must accompany improvements in infrastructure. She also believes mandatory employment quotas could eventually provide stronger guarantees than voluntary commitments.
There are reasonable arguments on both sides of the quota debate. Employers may resist inflexible targets, particularly where the availability of suitable candidates varies between sectors. But voluntary ambitions can also be quietly abandoned.
Milburn’s five-year review mechanism is an attempt to balance these considerations.
What remains unclear is how quickly the physical infrastructure of employment can be improved. Transport accessibility involves substantial capital investment, engineering, planning and coordination across multiple authorities.
It is a reminder that the barriers to employment often begin long before a young person reaches the workplace.
The invisible cost of digital exclusion
A related problem concerns the increasingly digital nature of recruitment.
Job applications, interviews, training courses and even access to public services are now routinely conducted online. Artificial intelligence is beginning to play a greater role in assessing candidates and identifying suitable applicants.
For young people without reliable computers, connectivity or digital skills, this creates another form of exclusion.
Elizabeth Anderson, chief executive of the Digital Poverty Alliance, argues that access to appropriate technology must become part of any serious strategy to reduce economic inactivity.
She points out that discussions about young people’s use of technology often concentrate on excessive screen time and social media. Yet access to a laptop can be essential for education, employment and training.
Research cited by the Alliance found that almost a third of parents reported increased interest in college among their children after receiving a laptop.
The distinction between owning a smartphone and having meaningful digital access is important.
A young person may be perfectly capable of using social media while lacking the equipment or confidence to prepare a CV, complete a complex application or participate in an online training course.
Anderson warns that digital exclusion could become even more consequential as artificial intelligence spreads through recruitment.
“We must empower young people with the tools to access opportunity, rather than punish them for not having them.”
There is a broader irony here. At precisely the moment when technology promises to make recruitment more efficient, it may also make the process less accessible to some of the people most in need of employment.
Kevin Chan of Epitome Global and Justin Madgwick of Resource Group Holdings, meanwhile, advocate a different use of technology: assessing transferable skills and potential rather than relying exclusively on qualifications, conventional CVs and rigid job descriptions.
This is a potentially valuable distinction. Artificial intelligence could reinforce existing recruitment biases by automating conventional selection criteria. Alternatively, properly designed systems might help employers identify candidates whose capabilities have been overlooked.
The technology itself does not determine which outcome will prevail. That depends on the choices made by employers and those designing recruitment systems.
The geography of opportunity
Milburn’s proposals also raise questions about where employment support should be delivered.
James Arrowsmith, a social care partner at Browne Jacobson, argues that the answer lies in closer integration between local healthcare, education, employment and social services.
He sees an opportunity to align Milburn’s proposals with the Government’s existing neighbourhood health and care agenda.
The logic is persuasive. A young person struggling with poor mental health, insecure housing and unemployment should not have to negotiate several unrelated bureaucracies to obtain help.
Arrowsmith also makes a wider economic point. Neighbourhood services do not merely support people in difficulty. They can create employment themselves, particularly in communities where opportunities are scarce.
There is, however, a danger that government creates overlapping local structures without adequately coordinating them.
The review envisages a locally led system in which young people have one point of access and one coherent plan. Delivering that will require more than new institutional names.
It will require schools, colleges, councils, health providers, employers and central government to share responsibility for outcomes.
And it will require an honest assessment of regional labour markets. A young person living in an area with limited public transport, few employers and weak training provision faces a very different set of circumstances from someone living near a major city with a thriving economy.
The same employment guarantee cannot have identical practical meaning in both places.
What does a good first job look like?
There is also a question about the quality of the opportunities being created.
Josh Harris, chief executive of creative agency Neverland, argues that conventional recruitment practices often exclude promising young people before they have had a chance to demonstrate their abilities.
“In advertising, talent is everywhere, but opportunity isn’t.”
His agency has established the Flying Academy, offering paid practical experience without requiring previous agency experience, particular qualifications or personal connections.
The significance of such initiatives lies in their willingness to reconsider what constitutes a suitable candidate.
Traditional recruitment often rewards evidence of previous opportunity. A prestigious internship, a polished CV or a strong professional network may indicate ability, but they may also reflect family resources and social advantage.
Removing unnecessary entry requirements can therefore reveal talent which would otherwise remain invisible.
Alex Goat, chief executive of youth consultancy Livity, takes the argument further. She welcomes the proposed guarantees but insists that the objective should be independence and long-term personal development, not simply the immediate reduction of unemployment statistics.
An offer of work, she argues, is of limited value if the young person cannot afford the journey, manage the hours or obtain the support needed to remain employed.
Her emphasis on independence is important because it introduces a different measure of success.
A six-month placement may reduce the NEET total temporarily. But does it lead to further employment? Does the young person gain transferable skills? Are they better able to support themselves? Have they acquired confidence and professional relationships?
These are more demanding questions than whether a vacancy has been filled.
They are also questions which employers should be prepared to answer.
The welfare question remains
The most politically sensitive aspect of Milburn’s review concerns the relationship between welfare support and participation.
The report proposes a new youth allowance alongside stronger expectations that young people should take up suitable opportunities. It also recommends maintaining support for the additional costs associated with disability, and providing greater security for those with severe lifelong conditions for whom paid employment is not realistic.
The intention is to distinguish between those who need help to participate and those whose circumstances require continuing financial protection.
In principle, this is a reasonable distinction. In practice, it will be extraordinarily difficult to administer.
Health conditions fluctuate. Mental health difficulties can be episodic. A young person may be capable of employment in one environment but not another. Someone may be able to work for a limited number of hours without being able to sustain full-time employment.
The danger is that a system designed to encourage participation becomes another elaborate mechanism for categorising young people according to assessments which cannot adequately capture their circumstances.
Milburn’s emphasis on individual support is therefore essential, not incidental, to the success of his proposals.
There is also a fundamental question about conditionality. If the state guarantees a credible opportunity and the young person declines it without good reason, it is reasonable to ask what obligations should follow. But if the promised opportunity is unsuitable, inaccessible or unsupported, the moral argument for sanctions becomes considerably weaker.
The quality of the guarantee must come before the enforcement of the obligation. That distinction will matter enormously as ministers develop the detailed legislation.
The challenge for government
Milburn deserves credit for producing a report which looks beyond the traditional boundaries of welfare policy.
Its most important insight may be that youth economic inactivity is not one problem but a collection of interconnected failures, beginning in childhood and extending through education, healthcare, transport, recruitment and workplace culture.
Yet this breadth creates its own difficulty. The Government can announce a hiring incentive relatively quickly. It cannot produce good managers, accessible transport networks, effective local institutions or stronger communities by ministerial instruction.
Nor can it assume that every young person outside education or employment faces the same obstacles.
A care leaver searching for their first stable job, a disabled graduate unable to travel reliably, a teenager with severe anxiety and a school leaver without qualifications may all appear in the same national statistics. Their needs are radically different.
The review’s proposals will succeed only if the system becomes sufficiently flexible to recognise those differences.
There is a further challenge in the changing economy. Artificial intelligence is already altering the organisation of entry-level work, particularly in occupations where junior employees have traditionally learned by performing routine tasks. Employers may need fewer people to undertake some of those tasks, even as new opportunities emerge elsewhere.
This makes the development of adaptability, judgement, communication and practical skills increasingly important.
It also means that government must avoid designing an employment system exclusively around the labour market as it exists today. Ultimately, the Milburn Review is a test not only of government but of British employers.
The state can reduce hiring costs, improve training provision and coordinate support. Businesses must decide whether they are willing to recognise potential, invest in inexperienced employees and create the conditions in which those employees can develop.
James Reed’s emphasis on management, Russell Winnard’s insistence on sustained support and Victoria Oliver’s warning about physical accessibility all point towards the same conclusion.
Employment is not simply a transaction between a vacancy and an applicant. It is a relationship between a person and a wider economic and social environment.
For too long, Britain has treated the problem of young people outside work as though the principal question were how to persuade them to enter it. Milburn has begun to ask a better question: what must society change to make participation possible?
But there is one final question which ministers must now answer. If the Government is prepared to guarantee young people an opportunity, is it equally prepared to guarantee the conditions which make that opportunity real?
That is where the success or failure of this ambitious review will ultimately be decided.