Magazine

Editors Pick

How eBay can be more than just a side-hustle

BBC News

Public sector pay deals help drive up UK borrowing

Borrowing was £17.4bn last month, the second highest October figure since monthly records began in 1993.

Tim Clark
19th November 2026

Tim Clark on Alan Milburn: this report “has had little or no involvement from schools”

Tim Clark

On 17th November, Alan Milburn published his final, “From a welfare state to a working state” report. He argues that the solution to the current NEETs crisis is not “another short-lived initiative, but by making the next generation a national priority.” Whether the report does mark a “watershed moment”, as claimed by the PM, remains to be seen (it is, after all, only an advisory report and many of the recommendations will have to await a White Paper and then legislation). There is no question, however, that the report does give prominence to the deep-rooted issues surrounding NEETs and the welfare system and, as Chris Mason has argued, makes a moral argument for welfare reforms rather than an argument “grounded in a specific objective to make benefits cuts to make the sums add up elsewhere.”

The purpose of this short paper is to look specifically at how the Report relates to schools and to analyse some of the comments and recommendations in Chapter 4, “Education: the bridge to the future” (a title not far removed from the Jobs Foundation’s “Jobs and Education: Building the Bridge to Opportunity” report, published in the summer).

There are a few phrases in the Report which suggest that Milburn has had little or no active involvement from schools. The comment that future-proofing young people by “giving them strong educational foundations and the personal aptitudes they need to sustain participation” should become a “new task the education system must now discharge if more young people are not to become NEET” is simply an insult to the profession: what have we been trying to do for decades, despite every hindrance placed in our way? Glib comments such as “I welcome the government’s decision to strengthen its guidance [on mobile ‘phone bans] so that schools move beyond a ‘not seen, not heard’ approach and ensure that mobile phones are genuinely inaccessible throughout the school day…. [to support] the goal of making schools phone free” are not substantiated. Is he in favour of providing schools with the necessary equipment to become phone free and does he support staff searching pupils’ bags and blazers for ‘phones? Realistic, practical advice is lacking. I also have to say that in terms of schools, there is absolutely nothing new in anything that Milburn suggests – a broader curriculum, the importance of early years, the need for work experience and effective careers education have all been suggested elsewhere.

That said, Milburn recognises that the best way to avoid becoming a NEET is to have a good education. “Good qualifications remain one of the strongest protections a young person can have against unemployment,” and “Good GCSE attainment significantly reduces the risk of becoming NEET.” He also recognises that education is about much more than exam results: “A knowledge-rich education should sit alongside sport, arts, enrichment, outdoor activity, strong relationships and opportunities for young people to discover interests and aptitudes.” There is, however, no advice on how schools should deliver such essentials at a time of squeezed budgets and teacher shortages.

As argued in my latest Finito report, “Schools and Employability”, Milburn accepts that despite the central importance of knowledge, knowledge on its own is not enough. “Knowledge matters, but so does the ability to apply it, communicate, work with others, solve problems and continue learning. Agility and adaptability will be essential….. But a new balance is needed:… putting aptitudes alongside knowledge.” As argued before, we do not want a sterile, utilitarian school system: preparing young people for work does not mean a narrow, employment-based education.

A good education is about the development of character and attitude, social and physical development as well as cognitive development. Education should not be about “employers’ immediate requirements” but about “possessing the foundations and social capital needed to navigate adult working life: gaining attributes like communication, collaboration and creativity alongside practical skills such as problem solving, time keeping, understanding basic workplace rights and expectations, responding to feedback and knowing how to ask for help. Social capital should not be inherited by accident. Education should help provide it deliberately.” Again, this is what good schools have always tried to achieve – well-rounded, self-disciplined, creative, inquisitive and motivated young people.

As argued in both “Schools and Employability” and the Jobs Foundation’s “Bridge to Opportunity”, the need for a broader curriculum is long overdue and the “one size fits all” approach to curriculum is simply wrong. “The task is not to dilute our definition of excellence but to broaden it by ensuring that the focus on rigour and standards that has been successfully applied over recent decades to the academic route is equally applied to the technical route….The curriculum should be designed to help more young people engage, uncover aptitude and achieve demanding standards… technical education should become a core part of what schools do…..”

New Vocational GCSEs should be available in some subjects from 2029, and there is no reason why these cannot sit alongside more traditional subjects. Again, as argued elsewhere, a broader curriculum will help behaviour, attendance and achievement: not prizes for all, but an acceptance that success does not look the same for everyone. What we must insist upon, however, is the highest standards in every subject, be it maths, English, construction, IT or bricklaying. Milburn rightly recognises the danger of a return to more vocational options, in that they could become “the preserve of children from lower income households, and academic education the route for middle and higher income ones.”

This is a very real danger and it is essential that curriculum choices are based solely on aptitude, ability and interest, and not on family socio-economic factors. That aside, however, the benefits of a broader, high-quality curriculum are plain to see: “Those countries with the lowest NEET rates in Europe have given the highest priority to vocational education. In the Netherlands, for example, 55% of upper secondary school students aged 15 to 19 are enrolled in vocational education. This rises to 68% in Austria. Both countries have sustained low NEET rates.” Even Singapore, often cited as having one of the highest-performing school systems in the world, has long placed technical and vocational education on a par with academic programmes.

On the issue of curriculum, Milburn does seem to be slightly contradictory. On the one hand, he wants to see technical/vocational courses sitting alongside more traditional subjects, yet he also praises both UTCs and the “UTC sleeve” approach [specialist pathways such as engineering, being run in mainstream secondary schools, alongside traditional curriculum pathways]. Such a breadth of curriculum is to be welcomed, but many UTCs do not offer humanities or modern languages in order to accommodate breadth. How do schools manage to balance breadth and standards, the general and the specific, choice and a common core curriculum? There has to be the recognition of a basic fact [a very basic fact, but one forgotten by many policymakers – the original National Curriculum was too large to fit into the school day!] that the school day is finite: pupils can’t do everything. To see youngsters not studying history, literature or a modern language in order to make room for construction is a mistake, not least because it is through such subjects that youngsters learn to question, to communicate, to reason, to think critically – the very attributes which employers crave. There is no easy answer, but curriculum balance needs to be approached rationally and realistically.

The emphasis on early years is to be welcomed. “Poor school-readiness correlates with worse outcomes many years later.” The charity Kindred2 has shown that by the age of 22 months, the future trajectory of most young people’s lives has already been determined and that almost half the attainment gap at GCSE is already evident by the age of five years old. The answer is not a return to Sure Start, about which the jury is still out and which was prohibitively expensive, but early years must be an immediate priority – intervention at primary school, let alone secondary school, is simply too late. Despite recognising the crucial importance of parents, there is also no suggestion of how to tackle those who refuse to engage with school or with relevant early years and parenting programmes.

As mentioned in several Finito reports, Milburn is quite right to point out that “as children only spend about a fifth of their waking hours in education [the common figure quoted is 17.5%], what happens outside the school gates also matters.” Indeed, I should argue that what happens beyond the school gates is not just a case of “also” mattering, but of being absolutely fundamental. It never fails to impress me just how much of a positive impact school does have on many youngsters, but if for the other 82.5% of their lives youngsters are in environments which are totally alien to, even antagonistic towards, the aims and mores of school, then the importance of early years, parenting and of wider society becomes even more evident.

There is no doubt that evidence proves the crucial importance of meaningful work experience. Milburn welcomes the government’s National Mission on Work Experience, calling on employers to create additional opportunities so that all young people have meaningful exposure to the workplace between the ages of 14 and 16, and also the requirement that schools have a statutory duty to provide work experience. But he does not seem to understand the difficulties involved: schools can only offer high-quality work experience if such opportunities are available (rural and coastal areas? Areas with limited employment opportunities?), if they have the staff to coordinate and monitor placements and if employers are prepared to offer placements. One recommendation by the Jobs Foundation is the introduction of a standardised framework to enable employers to engage with schools, covering such issues as safeguarding, liability cover and standardised documentation. Making something statutory is one thing: enabling it to happen is another.

Similarly, Milburn is right to argue that good careers guidance is critical and that it needs to be universal across all schools. Young people “can’t dream of a future they have never been shown” [Sir Martin Oliver, HMCI]. How are youngsters to know what an actuary, a foley artist or an ethical hacker do for a living if they do not find out in school (and if their parents do not hold such jobs)? Good-quality careers education is about broadening horizons, inspiring and motivating; it can also give a purpose and meaning to school which may not be immediately apparent. I also welcome the suggestion that destinations should become an accountability measure, alongside examination results. Such a move in terms of league tables and Ofsted inspections would highlight the importance to schools of looking beyond examinations and to how they prepare youngsters not only for employment, but for life.

Finally, I want to comment on two aspects of the Report that I think are both serious and worrying. Firstly, Milburn calls for a second new accountability measure, a “ready-for-work standard”, which evaluates whether the young person is prepared for the transition to work. Whilst on paper this may sound sensible, the practical difficulties are insurmountable. How does one assess objectively and equitably attributes such as cooperation, teamwork or inquisitiveness? Of course, teachers can tell you which pupils are pleasant, polite and helpful, but trying to evaluate, compare or rank the extent to which a pupil is pleasant, polite and helpful is fraught with difficulty.

A much better solution is the one recommended in every single Finito Better Schools report and in The Bridge to Opportunity, that is, the introduction of a non-academic leaving certificate that evaluates objective data by comparing a pupil’s attendance, punctuality, behaviour (in terms of detentions and suspensions) and engagement with wider school activities with both school and national data. Of course, there must always be the opportunity to explain any extenuating circumstances, but such a document would both provide employers with the very information they need, as well as provide schools with a tool to motivate and to improve pupil behaviour, attendance, punctuality and attitude.

The above criticism reveals a lack of understanding of the difficulties of assessment. The final criticism, however, reveals a lack of understanding of teachers, schools and the current crisis facing both. With apologies to regular readers who will know what I am about to say, the single biggest issue facing our schools is the current teacher recruitment and retention crisis – a crisis of both quality and quantity. Despite promises of 6,500 new teachers, there are almost 2,000 fewer teachers in the system than two years ago. And why is there a crisis? Every year the DfE produces data on why teachers leave the profession and for the last few years the top two reasons have been consistent – workload and stress.

Milburn, to his credit, actually recognises this, but what’s his answer? Do nothing – just give teachers more work. “444. Schools often feel overwhelmed by the multiple responsibilities they already face. In that context I have weighed up carefully whether the changes I have proposed can be justified. I believe they can. The current system is leaving too many young people at risk of becoming NEET. Something has to give.” Yes, something does have to give – something that reduces teachers’ workload, stress and demotivation. Similarly, paragraph 407 [“Every pupil at material risk of disengagement should be known by an adult in the school who understands their circumstances sufficiently to notice significant change. This does not require another new profession. It may be a form tutor, teacher, pastoral lead or another appropriate member of staff. They should be somebody’s responsibility”.] is blindingly obvious, inflammatory, in that you would be hard-pressed to find a school or teacher who did not already take this seriously and see it as part of their professional duty, and out of touch – the evidence clearly shows that the recent massive increase in teacher workload has been driven, at least in part, by an increase in pastoral issues (by declining pupil behaviour).

For all the criticisms I have made, I welcome Alan Milburn’s report and sincerely hope that it will lead to lasting, positive and effective changes to our school system that will benefit all young people and, in turn, benefit the economy and the very future of this country. What Milburn, the government and the DfE must recognise, however, is that our school system will only improve if, and only if, we have an adequate supply of highly trained, highly motivated and highly effective teachers. This should be a national priority.

Employability Portal

University Careers Service Rankings.
Best Global Cities to Work in.
Mentor Directory.
HR heads.

Useful Links

Education Committee
Work & Pensions
Business Energy
Working
Employment & Labour
Multiverse
BBC Worklife
Mentoring Need to Know
Listen to our News Channel 9:00am - 5.00pm weekdays
Finito and Finito World are trade marks of the owner. We cannot accept responsibility for unsolicited submissions, manuscripts and photographs. All prices and details are correct at time of going to press, but subject to change. We take no responsibility for omissions or errors. Reproduction in whole or in part without the publisher’s written permission is strictly prohibited. All rights reserved.
© 2026 Finito World - All Rights Reserved.